My Account | Cart  | Log In
  Blue Book on FaceBook   Blue Book on Twitter   Blue Book on YouTube   Blue Book on InstaGram
Products ▼ FFL Solutions Company ▼ Information & Services ▼ Subscriptions ▼

Gun Of The Week by S.P. Fjestad

Gun of the Week image   The Gun of the Week is an exclusive editorial article that highlights a different gun each week. The guns featured represent some of the finest and most desirable collectible firearms available in today’s marketplace as well as many common guns that are encountered on a regular basis by many shooters and collectors. Carefully written captions provide interesting and comprehensive information, and up-to-date values are included for an in-depth article you won’t find anywhere else! Check back each Monday for a new Gun of the Week.
New! When a Pair Beats a Royal Flush   
How To Lose $150,000 On One Gun In 2 1/2 Years!   
Auction Purchased Winchester Model 1866 Rifle   
How To Walk Away From A Gun Deal by Kurt House and S.P. & Z.R. Fjestad   
Colt SAA Rusty Dug-Up   

Colt SAA Rusty Dug-Up

Trash or Treasure? The answer (and the price) will surprise you!

I know what you’re thinking, and it’s wrong. How can a rusty dug-up like this Colt SAA possibly have any value left? After all, obviously, this revolver can no longer be fired or even loaded. The ejector rod housing, trigger, loading gate, and part of the grips are missing. There isn’t even one remaining part left that is salvageable or saleable. No, this SAA wasn’t “found” recently in a creek bed close to Custer’s Last Stand, and has no provenance or documented history (that could change, depending on the next owner). You can’t even get a factory letter from Colt, since the serial numbers have long since disappeared during the decades of rusting underground. The only good news is that it doesn’t have to be cleaned any more!

So does this rusty dug-up mean it also has a subterranean value? Maybe not. So why is it still valuable? Because of the coolness factor and it represents real history. Believe it or not, this is also the rarest original condition factor of any SAA. After all, it took maybe a century of underground aging to get this revolver to its current condition.

This Colt was auctioned off at Rock Island Auctions’ online auction this past weekend. The pre-auction estimate was $700-$1,100, and that price range is NOT a typo. Don’t forget a new 3rd Generation Colt SAA sells for around $1,200. I put in a spread bid for $650, and believe it or not, it sold for $1,092.50, including the 15% buyer’s premium!!

One last thing and it’s important. What did we learn once the cyberspace auction bidding stopped on this gun? Probably that it’s the perfect platform (storm?) for two or more crazed bidders to establish an unrealistic high price for a rusty dug-up that represents America’s Western heritage – not a fair market value.

Image and some information courtesy of Rock Island Auctions.


Our Value Guides Other Products Subscriptions Information Services
Current Value Guides
Deluxe Value Guides
Previous Value Guides
Special Offers
Black Powder
Colt Engraving
Access My Subscription
Purchase/Renew Subscription
Lookup My Model
Removed Manufacturer List
Firearm Grading
Press Releases
Privacy Policy
Affiliate Program
Appraisals & Evaluations

Blue Book's Top Ten
S.P. Fjestad's Lethal Blogging
The Armed Librarian by Charles Priore
Remembering R.L. Wilson
Find this page helpful? Please click the g+1 button to let Google know!
  ©2017 Blue Book Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.